[新聞] 金融時報：台灣表示WHO未對武漢肺炎預警

作者: pikakami (神�b�竣W) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 金融時報：台灣表示WHO未對武漢肺炎預警
時間: Fri Mar 20 22:52:34 2020

※發文無1~6小標格式或未依順序任意刪除者會被刪文

1.媒體來源:
※ 例如蘋果日報、自由時報（請參考版規下方的核准媒體名單）
英國金融時報

2.記者署名
※ 沒有在這打上記者署名的新聞會被水桶14天 編輯非記者
※ 外電至少要有來源或編輯 如:法新社
Reporting by Primrose Riordan in Hong Kong, Katrina Manson in Washington,
Kathrin Hille in Taipei and Clive Cookson in London

3.完整新聞標題:
※ 標題沒有完整寫出來 ---> 依照板規刪除文章
Taiwan says WHO failed to act on coronavirus transmission warning
台灣表示WHO未能對武漢肺炎傳播做出預警
Relationship with Beijing blamed for not sharing alert over human-to-human
infection
與北京的關係被責難於在人傳人感染上沒有共享情報

4.完整新聞內文:
※ 社論特稿都不能貼！違者刪除（政治類水桶3個月)，貼廣告也會被刪除喔！可詳看版規
Taiwan has accused the World Health Organization of failing to communicate an
early warning about transmission of the coronavirus between humans, slowing
the global response to the pandemic.

台灣指責WHO未能在武漢肺炎人傳人感染發出預警，減緩了全球對此流行病的應對。

Health officials in Taipei said they alerted the WHO at the end of December
about the risk of human-to-human transmission of the new virus but said its
concerns were not passed on to other countries.

台北的衛生官員表示，他們在 [1;33m12月底 [m就這種新病毒的人傳人風險向WHO發出了警告，但WHO沒
有向其他國家傳達這種憂心。

Taiwan is excluded from the WHO because China, which claims it as part of its
territory, demands that third countries and international bodies do not treat
it in any way that resembles how independent states are treated.

台灣被排除在WHO之外，係因為中國要求第三國、國際組織不要以任何類似於獨立國家的方
式對待台灣。中國宣稱台灣是其領土的一部分。

The WHO's relationship with China has been criticised in the past, with some
accusing the organisation of overly praising Beijing's handling of the
coronavirus outbreak despite allegations local officials had initially
covered it up.

WHO與中國的關係在過去曾受到批評，有人指責WHO過分地稱讚北京處理武漢肺炎疫情的方
式，儘管當地官員最初曾經被指控掩蓋事實。

Taiwan said its doctors had heard from mainland colleagues that medical staff
were getting ill — a sign of human-to-human transmission. Taipei officials
said they reported this to both International Health Regulations (IHR), a WHO
framework for exchange of epidemic prevention and response data between 196
countries, and Chinese health authorities on December 31.

台灣表示，台灣醫生從中國籍同事那裡聽說，醫務人員正在染病——這是人傳人的跡象。
台北官員表示，他們已於 [1;33m12月31日 [m向《國際衛生條例》（IHR）和中國衛生當局報告了這一
情況。《國際衛生條例》是世衛組織在196個國家之間，交換疫情控制和應對數據的架構。

Taiwanese government officials told the Financial Times the warning was not
shared with other countries.

台灣政府官員告訴金融時報，這份警告並沒有傳達給其他國家。

"While the IHR's internal website provides a platform for all countries to
share information on the epidemic and their response, none of the information
shared by our country's [Centers for Disease Control] is being put up there,
" said Chen Chien-jen, Taiwan's vice-president.

台灣副總統陳建仁表示：「雖然說《國際衛生條例》的內部網站為所有國家提供了一個共
享疫情資訊及其應對措施的平台，但我國（疾管署）分享的訊息並沒有出現在那裡。」

The WHO could not obtain first-hand information to study and judge whether
there was human-to-human transmission of Covid-19. This led it to announce
human-to-human transmission with a delay, and an opportunity to raise the
alert level both in China and the wider world was lost," said Mr Chen, an
epidemiologist by training who was health minister at the time of the Sars
outbreak.

陳建仁表示，WHO無法獲得第一手資料來研究、判斷COVID-19病毒是否存在人傳人的現象。
這導致WHO延後宣布人傳人的發生，失去一個在中國，乃至於全世界提高警戒級別的機會。
陳建仁是一名受過培訓的流行病學家，曾在SARS爆發時擔任衛生部長（衛生署長）。

China's health ministry only confirmed human-to-human transmission on
January 20, after the WHO said in mid-January there might be "limited"
human-to-human transmission but stepped back from this view on the same day.

中國衛生部在1月20日才確認人傳人。此前WHO在1月中曾經表示，可能存在「有限度的」人
傳人，但同一天又放棄了這個觀點。

Asked about the comments, the WHO said under its mandate it needed trust to "
hold frank and open discussions on sometimes sensitive issues" and to enable
this level of candour "requires that we respect the confidentiality of such
communications". Western countries have since been accused of failing to act
even when they were warned about human-to-human transmission.

在被問及這些評論時，WHO表示，根據授權，它需要信賴，以便「有時就敏感的問題進行坦
誠、公開的討論」，並「要求我們尊重此類溝通的保密性」，以讓這種程度的坦誠成為可
能。之後西方國家一直被指責未能採取行動，即使有人警告它們注意人傳人。

The WHO has had to strike a delicate balance with China throughout the
outbreak, with some accusing the organisation of being too pliant while
medical experts said it had coped admirably.

在整個疫情爆發期間，WHO不得不與中國保持微妙的平衡，一些人指責WHO過於聽話，而一
些醫學專家表示，WHO的應對令人敬佩。

The challenge of managing the relationship extended to negotiations over the
wording of a report following a joint mission to China last month. The
nine-day trip comprised 12 WHO experts and 13 Chinese officials and was
focused on the country's response to the outbreak. Three of the WHO
officials also visited Wuhan, the centre of the outbreak, as part of the
mission.

處理雙方關係的挑戰，還延伸到上月聯合訪問中國之後，關於一份報告措辭的談判。為期
九天的訪問，由12名世衛組織專家和13名中國官員組成，重點關心於中國對疫情的反應。
WHO的三名官員還作為訪問團的一部分訪問了疫情中心武漢。

The WHO's Bruce Aylward, the Canadian epidemiologist who led the team,
described the process as "fantastic". But he told the FT there was "huge
back and forth" with Chinese officials about what went into the report.

WHO的Bruce Aylward，領導該小組的加拿大籍傳染病學家，形容過程是「fantastic」的，
但他對金融時報表示，對於報告的內容，中國官員「反反覆覆討論」。

Dr Aylward said Chinese health officials did not want to refer to the
pathogen as "dangerous" as they regarded such terminology as reserved for
diseases with higher mortality rates.

Aylward博士表示，中國衛生官員不希望將這種病原體稱作「危險」，因為他們認為這種術
語只適用於死亡率較高的疾病。

Chinese health officials also refused to include any reference to avoiding a
"second wave" of coronavirus in the report, he said, so they compromised on
"a surge" or "resurgence".

他說，中國衛生官員也拒絕在報告中提及避免武漢肺炎的「第二波」，因此他們在
「surge」（暴增）或「resurgence」（再現）上妥協。

Dale Fisher, an infectious disease specialist at the National University of
Singapore, said the team's Chinese counterparts requested the report not
make reference to a "dangerous pathogen" because they said it had a "
bioterrorism type suggestion", so they found a replacement.

新加坡國立大學（NUS）的傳染病專家Dale Fisher表示，中國方面要求報告不要提及「危
險病原體」，因為他們認為這是一種「生化恐怖主義式的暗示」，所以他們找到了一種替
代詞。

Clifford Lane, clinical director of America's National Institute of Allergy
and Infectious Diseases who was one of two US officials on the mission, said
the WHO team's Chinese members had "a great desire to be precise". He said
the debates over wording did not amount to censorship but represented a "bit
of spin".

美國國家過敏和傳染病研究所臨床科主任Clifford Lane是參與此次任務的兩名美國官員之
一。他表示，WHO工作組的中國成員「非常希望做到精確」。他表示，圍繞措辭的爭論並不
等同於審查工作，而是 [1;33m「有點鬼扯」 [m。

China's ministry of health did not respond to requests for comment.

中國衛生部對此不表示評論。

Despite the criticism, the WHO has impressed many medical professionals and
public health experts with its speed and effectiveness.

儘管存在這些批評，WHO其速度和效力給許多醫療人士和公共衛生專家留下了深刻印象。

"The WHO has filled its leadership role admirably," said Mark Woolhouse,
professor of infectious disease epidemiology at Edinburgh University. "
Though you could quibble a bit about timings, they have done all the right
things so far."

愛丁堡大學的傳染病學家Mark Woolhouse表示，WHO出色地發揮了其領導作用。 「雖然你
可以對時間問題吹毛求疵，但迄今為止，他們做的一切都是正確的。 」

Dr Aylward added that whenever Chinese officials were reluctant to carry out
a request or grant him access or were taken aback at his demands, he would
always answer: "You can't rule out another Wuhan if you don't know how and
when this started."

Aylward博士補充說，每當中國官員不情願執行一項請求或不願讓他進入，或對他的要求感
到吃驚時，他總是會回答，「如果你不知道這是何時如何開始的，你就沒辦法排除另一個
武漢。」

He said that was always "the trigger point for them".

他說這總是「他們之間的導火線」。

"They don't want another Wuhan," he said.

「他們不想看到另一個武漢」，他說。

5.完整新聞連結 (或短網址):
※ 當新聞連結過長時，需提供短網址方便網友點擊
https://www.ft.com/content/2a70a02a-644a-11ea-a6cd-df28cc3c6a68

6.備註:
※ 一個人一天只能張貼一則新聞，被刪或自刪也算額度內，超貼者水桶，請注意
評論區
Libararian21
66人按讚
The Chinese Communist Party's impact on the world is truly insidious. At
least the Soviets were poor.

Juviens
43人按讚
China , the world should and will not forget what your rotten dictatorial
system caused . The exclusion of Taiwan ( one of the few countries which
reacted admirably against the virus ) from WHO's information / decision
network at the instigation of China is nothing but criminal and both WHO
leadership and Xi carry the responsibility .

--
[1;31m→ [33mchinaviva [m [33m:人家這麼說　你也這麼說　有沒有點獨立思維啊 [m 01/04 15:52
[1;31m→ [33mchinaviva [m [33m:按你的邏輯　三人為�g　繁體的眾字也能叫眾？ [m 01/04 15:52
[1;31m→ [33mchinaviva [m [33m:繁體的憂無心　簡體的�怞酗腄@無心何來憂？ [m 01/04 15:54
[1;31m→ [33mchinaviva [m [33m:繁體哪個三個人？那個中間的也算人？ [m 01/04 15:55
[1;31m→ [33mchinaviva [m [33m:英文的愛沒有心　阿拉伯的愛也沒有心　比繁體字低級? [m 01/04 16:08

--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 140.116.132.127 (臺灣)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1584715958.A.176.html
[1;31m→ [33mhttps [m [33m: 預警三小 426都直接封武漢一個月讓你看了 [m 123.205.150.5 03/20 22:53
[1;31m→ [33mMrXD [m [33m: 自立自強 不然 誰理你們 [m 36.235.116.52 03/20 22:53
[1;37m推 [33mdearjohn307 [m [33m: https://www.ettoday.net/news/202 [m 223.137.6.58 03/20 22:53
[1;37m推 [33mrednah [m [33m: 賤人石鐘上蠢屌打who [m 180.204.147.51 03/20 22:54
[1;31m→ [33mhttps [m [33m: 就沒人料到會全世界傳染 在那邊馬後炮 [m 123.205.150.5 03/20 22:54
台灣12月就傳資料過去了
[1;37m推 [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 繁體就是支那豬的文字自以為不是 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 22:54
[1;37m推 [33mlkkgotyy [m [33m: 簽名黨是低能兒喔 [m 129.7.0.86 03/20 22:54
[1;37m推 [33mhyuchi0202 [m [33m: 不要怕 現在全世界有很多武漢了 [m 111.250.72.241 03/20 22:55
[1;37m推 [33mmusicaledio [m [33m: 到處都是武漢 別想怪支那 [m 27.247.166.169 03/20 22:56
[1;37m推 [33mjohnny9667 [m [33m: 你們外國人活該 誰叫台灣不在WHO [m 36.226.220.129 03/20 22:56
[1;37m推 [33mlight20735 [m [33m: who就是垃圾 [m 42.73.204.131 03/20 22:57
[1;37m推 [33msleepyrat [m [33m: 何時"台灣表示"變得這麼重要?? [m 1.174.85.201 03/20 22:57
[1;37m推 [33ml8 [m [33m: 封武漢是1/23的事，這篇文章講的是去年12月 [m 36.236.139.113 03/20 22:58
[1;31m→ [33mfluffylove [m [33m: 武漢封成那樣，歐洲還不當回事？ [m 150.117.43.2 03/20 22:58
奇怪是文章太長沒人看完嗎= =
※ 編輯: pikakami (140.116.132.127 臺灣), 03/20/2020 23:00:33
[1;37m推 [33mBURNFISH [m [33m: 推翻譯 [m 39.8.2.218 03/20 22:59
[1;37m推 [33mBingLing [m [33m: CHO [m 1.163.232.74 03/20 22:59
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 美國1/3號就知道了 一樣當耳邊風 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:00
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 歐美早就知道是小感冒 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:00
[1;37m推 [33mtryit015124 [m [33m: 簽名檔明顯是中國人 笑死 [m 8.39.127.184 03/20 23:00
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 2009年H1N1大流行還不是恐慌 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:00
[1;37m推 [33mLionKing [m [33m: 信WHO的都爆了 [m 114.45.125.143 03/20 23:00
[1;31m噓 [33mheci1941 [m [33m: https://i.imgur.com/eM3OwGl.jpg [m223.137.166.103 03/20 23:01
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 當年死亡率為2% 現在大家當小感冒 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:01
[1;31m→ [33mrx1342 [m [33m: WHO到現在除了要錢有做過什麼事嗎 [m 36.234.51.107 03/20 23:01
[1;37m推 [33maCCQ [m [33m: 就算早點知道又怎麼樣? 估計也是不會有作為 [m 119.14.176.11 03/20 23:01
[1;37m推 [33mEIKD [m [33m: 簽名檔那�l蠢，可能這波已經掛了吧 [m 42.76.148.105 03/20 23:01
[1;31m→ [33maCCQ [m [33m: 歐美的那一些專家學者都跟白癡一樣 [m 119.14.176.11 03/20 23:01
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 歐美跟WHO又無關 比亞洲多2個月準備 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:01
[1;37m推 [33mroute666 [m [33m: 12/31台灣已經向who示警有新興類sars病 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:01
[1;37m推 [33mdavidwen [m [33m: 給歐美人準備兩個月 還是沒有用 [m118.168.237.159 03/20 23:02
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 還是不準備 那表示就是小感冒 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:02
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 毒。也就是李文亮他們傳訊息時候。可是w [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:02
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: ho,一直不示警。還跟中國一搭一唱可訪可 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:03
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 又怎樣 台灣還不是聽中國說的 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:03
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 控。還不准其他國家跟中國斷航。 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:03
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 病毒就從中國過年時候大量傳播出去 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:04
[1;37m推 [33mdetective14r [m [33m: 某p是邏輯有問題嗎?中國的病毒 [m 36.226.223.101 03/20 23:04
[1;37m推 [33mnewstarisme [m [33m: #ChineseVirus [m 115.82.172.62 03/20 23:04
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 而西方國家就是因為相信who，五毛還好意 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:04
[1;31m→ [33mdetective14r [m [33m: 當然是聽中國說的阿 [m 36.226.223.101 03/20 23:04
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 思說給西方兩個月。你們從一開始就一直 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:04
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 散佈流感更可怕的謠言。還翻譯成各種語 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:05
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 言。who二月初就該宣布全球大流行 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:05
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 就為了配合習近平，所以讓全世界淪陷 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:06
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 中國就是最噁心的病毒。 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:06
[1;31m→ [33mtenka92417 [m [33m: 那時只有在中國大陸大流行的疾病叫全 [m 36.231.67.42 03/20 23:06
[1;31m→ [33mtenka92417 [m [33m: 球大流行哦 [m 36.231.67.42 03/20 23:06
[1;37m推 [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 西方國家最好相信WHO 別腦屌了 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:06
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 美國第一時間就封中國航線了 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:06
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 還不是爆爆樂 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:07
[1;37m推 [33msin27 [m [33m: WHO的反應應該是令人敬佩的聽話吧（翻白眼 [m 223.139.183.98 03/20 23:07
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 中共很噁心，而五毛可割可棄還會幫中共 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:07
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 歐洲最慘的義大利 第一時間封中台港 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 澳 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 別忘了 義大利封台灣也同時封中國 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 宣揚中共的好。你們真的腦子有在思考嗎 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 結果爆最慘 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 別忘了 義大利封台灣也同時封中國 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:08
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 結果爆最慘 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:09
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 領那五毛，死一堆五毛中共有道歉過嗎 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:09
[1;37m推 [33micecastle [m [33m: 文字遊戲的背後 是以人命作代價 [m122.121.100.147 03/20 23:09
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 要不我在跟你講以色列 第一時間鎖國 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:09
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 都要五毛感恩輕視你們韭菜的權貴沒讓你 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:09
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 要不我在跟你講以色列 第一時間鎖國 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:09
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 要不我在跟你講以色列 第一時間鎖國 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:10
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 們全滅呢。死個幾千萬人中共也不在意。 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:10
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 你去看以色列現在幾例 7百多例快破千 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:10
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 你去看以色列現在幾例 7百多例快破千 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:10
[1;37m推 [33mpeiring [m [33m: 五毛一堆 [m 101.10.5.58 03/20 23:10
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 反觀一直不封中國的日本 反而沒爆炸 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:10
[1;37m推 [33mmatchkiwi [m [33m: 五毛現在就是洗歐美自己不注意的風向啊 [m 1.171.154.197 03/20 23:10
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 反觀一直不封中國的日本 反而沒爆炸 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 你們到底在為誰努力啊？連嘴自己政府， [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 封中國的爆炸 不封中國的沒爆炸 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:11
[1;37m推 [33miMANIA [m [33m: 被共產黨滲透的世界組織都變成廢物 可笑 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 改變自己政府都不敢，也不能。一群只會 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 封中國的爆炸 不封中國的沒爆炸 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 你說WHO對還是錯 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33maCCQ [m [33m: 所以才說他們的專家學者都是白癡 [m 119.14.176.11 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33mroute666 [m [33m: 吠別人，幫自己爭取權益都不敢的懦夫 [m 36.226.11.74 03/20 23:11
[1;31m→ [33maCCQ [m [33m: 鎖國就認為沒事了 [m 119.14.176.11 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 垃圾習近平 <==這算嘴中國嗎route666 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33miMANIA [m [33m: 只提日本 怎不提親中的伊朗、義大利 笑死 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 人渣習近平+人渣蔡英文+人渣韓國瑜 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33mmatchkiwi [m [33m: 再過一陣子中國就會消失在這次肺炎文獻 [m 1.171.154.197 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 義大利第一時間封鎖中國台灣香港 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:12
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 義大利第一時間封鎖中國台灣香港 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:13
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 結果爆最慘 活該啊 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:13
[1;31m→ [33miMANIA [m [33m: 別忽略義大利一堆中國黑工 對了 伊朗呢? [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:13
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 封中國的都死最慘 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:13
[1;37m推 [33mwsx26997785 [m [33m: 推 [m 61.223.225.43 03/20 23:13
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 第一時間鎖國的以色列也爆了 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:13
[1;31m→ [33miMANIA [m [33m: 護航護這麼難看 只會顯得此地無銀三百兩 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:14
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 不過韓國以色列醫療都屌打台灣 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:14
[1;37m推 [33mmatchkiwi [m [33m: 這種完全扭曲前因後果的論點有夠可悲 [m 1.171.154.197 03/20 23:14
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 台灣死亡率廢到笑 高得要死 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:15
[1;37m推 [33mrunronrun [m [33m: WHO就是笑話 [m114.136.179.155 03/20 23:15
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 大概就是治療沒能力 只好靠防疫去補 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:15
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 習近平是人渣 who不是笑話是神組織 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:16
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 德國 以色列 新加坡 韓國 死亡率都低 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:16
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 過支那糞海島 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:16
[1;37m推 [33mbekinoko [m [33m: poweroflove是新加坡人吧 [m 42.74.58.98 03/20 23:17
[1;31m→ [33mbekinoko [m [33m: 他罵中共也不會怎樣 [m 42.74.58.98 03/20 23:17
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 頂尖醫療期刊lancet統計1990~2015 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:18
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 各國長期的醫療治療能力 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:18
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 25年的數據 台灣醫療排45名 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:18
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: https://imgur.com/br9XWZ6 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:18
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: https://imgur.com/p8EhS9s [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:19
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 在亞洲區被星日韓電 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:19
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 25年有如棒球員的生崖數據 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:19
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 所以台灣治療力差 最好靠防疫彌補 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:19
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 台灣的政策是用防疫彌補中上的醫療 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:20
[1;31m噓 [33mscoop [m [33m: 大外宣 [m 1.34.158.230 03/20 23:21
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 但是日本/韓國/德國/星國因為有前25 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:21
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: lancet的醫療實力排名 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:21
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 所以不用放太多心力在防疫 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:21
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 韓國死亡率1.1% 德國0.3% 台灣1.8% [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:23
[1;37m推 [33mcbr0627 [m [33m: 領先全球 [m 203.145.94.68 03/20 23:25
[1;31m→ [33milovebmw [m [33m: 最北七的就是當初跟支那建交 [m 110.26.2.239 03/20 23:27
[1;37m推 [33miMANIA [m [33m: 要幫高調才對 這篇報導寫得還不錯 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:28
原本想轉武肺版，不過好像不能轉？
[1;37m推 [33maccess4096 [m [33m: poweroflove 是自認為是新加坡人的台 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:28
[1;31m→ [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 灣人 不用對他的話認真 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:28
※ 編輯: pikakami (140.116.132.127 臺灣), 03/20/2020 23:29:52
[1;37m推 [33mfoxey [m [33m: 好好一篇文被一個洗板的搞到失焦 [m 59.124.242.209 03/20 23:29
[1;37m推 [33miMANIA [m [33m: 認同a大 他只是想模糊這篇新聞的焦點而已 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:30
[1;37m推 [33makway [m [33m: 先知 [m 223.137.59.141 03/20 23:30
[1;31m→ [33mfoxey [m [33m: 那隻之前不是分身被桶了? [m 59.124.242.209 03/20 23:31
→ QQMMWA: 換句話說年輕人感染後 死亡率 只有萬分之2 03/10 23:16
→ QQMMWA: 結論:我希望武漢病毒快感染我 我根本不怕 03/10 23:17
還有safelyfuck、Datamaster吧
※ 編輯: pikakami (140.116.132.127 臺灣), 03/20/2020 23:33:56
[1;37m推 [33miMANIA [m [33m: 可以轉nCoV2019版吧 [m 118.233.4.22 03/20 23:32
[1;37m推 [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 我新加坡永居我當過新加坡兵沒當過台 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:32
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 台灣兵 我為新加坡共和國戰死沙場 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:33
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 在所不惜 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:33
是你住蔡厝港嗎？有點忘了
※ 編輯: pikakami (140.116.132.127 臺灣), 03/20/2020 23:34:22
[1;37m推 [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 不過poweroflove 的同胞在新加坡版把 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:34
[1;31m→ [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 你永桶 嘻嘻 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:34
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 台人統的吧 台人哪是我同胞 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:35
[1;31m→ [33mpoweroflove [m [33m: 新加坡版=台人赴星觀光版 [m 209.58.163.145 03/20 23:36
[1;37m推 [33mSzss [m [33m: 武漢組織就是戰犯 [m 101.14.204.169 03/20 23:41
[1;37m推 [33mccjj8 [m [33m: 在座的各位全都是垃圾 [m 114.136.128.85 03/20 23:42
[1;37m推 [33mgerg [m [33m: 推 [m 223.139.26.184 03/20 23:43
[1;37m推 [33ms81048112 [m [33m: power不繼續吹新加玻啦????? [m 27.246.107.148 03/20 23:44
[1;37m推 [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 新加坡不太妙 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:44
[1;31m→ [33mfoolfighter [m [33m: 垃圾組織 [m 223.137.45.58 03/20 23:45
[1;31m→ [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 隔壁馬來西亞鎖國 雖然政府掛保證 但 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:46
[1;31m→ [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 難保證隨時會被斷物資 [m 223.139.9.75 03/20 23:46
[1;37m推 [33mSabo5566 [m [33m: 邏輯北七在亂推文 [m 180.204.204.15 03/20 23:51
[1;37m推 [33mr5e97nk63 [m [33m: 五毛會說野雞小報 [m 118.160.15.127 03/20 23:57
[1;37m推 [33mpeggy91522 [m [33m: 推 [m 111.82.79.170 03/20 23:57
[1;37m推 [33mfreends123 [m [33m: 新聞很好 但推文有人愛支病發作很礙眼 [m 223.137.73.127 03/20 23:59
[1;37m推 [33mstewartqq [m [33m: 推~ [m 1.173.105.190 03/21 00:00
[1;31m→ [33mjackz [m [33m: 新加坡低能兒 [m218.164.113.179 03/21 00:01
[1;37m推 [33mynntk4815 [m [33m: 封中國的爆炸 <- 阿怎麼有個假新人自婊 [m122.116.234.101 03/21 00:01
[1;37m推 [33mtuna0214 [m [33m: 新加坡人要不要照照鏡子 [m 39.8.224.213 03/21 00:02
[1;37m推 [33mupeo [m [33m: 台灣大順風 [m 101.137.215.76 03/21 00:03
[1;37m推 [33mjoker00507 [m [33m: 新加坡舔起來當什麼狗官垃圾鼻屎國 [m 27.52.62.238 03/21 00:03
[1;37m推 [33mjansec [m [33m: 謝謝翻譯 一些亂人的想帶什麼風向呢 [m 1.163.103.57 03/21 00:04
[1;37m推 [33mrayse [m [33m: 不要說當初了 現在還是一堆人相信這沒流感 [m180.204.227.135 03/21 00:08
[1;31m→ [33mrayse [m [33m: 可怕 人對第一印象的權威資料本來就會相信 [m180.204.227.135 03/21 00:08
[1;31m→ [33mrayse [m [33m: 而第一印象是很難扭轉的 有看人把伊波拉 [m180.204.227.135 03/21 00:08
[1;31m→ [33mrayse [m [33m: 當小感冒嗎？ [m180.204.227.135 03/21 00:08
[1;37m推 [33mgdth697 [m [33m: 台灣什麼時候... [m 223.141.170.52 03/21 00:09
[1;31m→ [33mjoliegwen [m [33m: 說個笑話WHO [m 223.136.71.166 03/21 00:09
[1;31m→ [33mjyue [m [33m: 怎麼想都是CHO失職... [m 61.64.176.226 03/21 00:10
[1;37m推 [33msusuqi [m [33m: 生氣什麼啦哈哈哈哈哈 [m 39.10.73.215 03/21 00:12
[1;37m推 [33mffreakk [m [33m: 沒有比台灣更了解中共的 [m 49.216.63.53 03/21 00:13
[1;37m推 [33mmatchkiwi [m [33m: 他現在換洗別篇了XD [m 1.171.154.197 03/21 00:14
[1;37m推 [33mfragmentwing [m [33m: 各種隱瞞叫做一直做正確的事www [m 42.74.213.31 03/21 00:16
[1;37m推 [33mWillier [m [33m: 偽新加坡人怎麼還沒被捅 [m 101.12.140.102 03/21 00:19
[1;37m推 [33mCCfss [m [33m: 最後的結論還是捧WHO啊 [m 118.169.33.253 03/21 00:23
[1;37m推 [33mnotneme159 [m [33m: 幫推幫高調 [m 111.71.125.28 03/21 00:24
[1;37m推 [33mCCfss [m [33m: 愛丁堡專家說這是吹毛求疵，WHO是正確的 [m 118.169.33.253 03/21 00:26
[1;31m噓 [33mprettiestmrs [m [33m: 噓簽名檔 [m 79.191.42.140 03/21 00:32
[1;31m噓 [33mmicotosai [m [33m: 新加婆大濕你又發病重複推文呀？ [m 123.192.85.106 03/21 00:35
[1;37m推 [33mLandsknecht [m [33m: 居然有人不認識簽名檔 [m 223.136.40.171 03/21 00:36
[1;37m推 [33mgoldflower [m [33m: poweroflove畜生到處洗XD [m 123.0.55.22 03/21 00:37
[1;37m推 [33mwawo58487 [m [33m: 那個愛丁堡的專家呵呵 [m 220.141.69.126 03/21 00:43
[1;37m推 [33mo0kk0ogreen [m [33m: 好啦，我們副總統聖騎士要退了，當一 [m 36.225.122.111 03/21 00:43
[1;31m→ [33mo0kk0ogreen [m [33m: 下你們的秘書長，屈就一下啦 [m 36.225.122.111 03/21 00:43
[1;37m推 [33muf1276 [m [33m: 假新仔這種發病起來比武漢肺炎還可怕 [m118.150.244.121 03/21 00:44
[1;37m推 [33mbiggest1983 [m [33m: 笨蛋不會感冒，簽名檔應該活得很好 [m 220.141.1.80 03/21 00:44
[1;37m推 [33mabc1212050 [m [33m: 是不是當初要開個國際記者會 警告who [m 101.136.96.252 03/21 00:46
[1;31m→ [33mabc1212050 [m [33m: 根本沒屁用 [m 101.136.96.252 03/21 00:46
[1;37m推 [33mLAN620 [m [33m: 出事了才會檢討 台灣被霸凌這些國家在哪 [m 114.35.217.105 03/21 00:47
[1;37m推 [33mtigertanktwo [m [33m: 推\ [m 49.216.189.161 03/21 00:47
[1;37m推 [33mLAN620 [m [33m: 默許單位用錢收買 全世界要賠上數萬倍代價 [m 114.35.217.105 03/21 00:55
[1;37m推 [33msath [m [33m: 假新加坡人那幾個帳號大家都知道了 切個屁 [m 1.171.25.204 03/21 00:55
[1;37m推 [33mjaeomes [m [33m: 簽名檔就realtw的啊 [m 115.82.227.192 03/21 00:58
[1;37m推 [33mndtoseooqd [m [33m: 再舔共嘛 [m 114.43.114.2 03/21 01:02
[1;37m推 [33mHNO3 [m [33m: 現在才知道？ [m 223.137.58.116 03/21 01:18
[1;31m→ [33mYuenYang5566 [m [33m: 貼比爾的話是想證明什麼啊，他是病 [m 42.77.186.169 03/21 01:23
[1;31m→ [33mYuenYang5566 [m [33m: 學專家？ [m 42.77.186.169 03/21 01:23
[1;37m推 [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 假新加坡人 被各大版水桶 只能來這裡 [m 223.139.9.75 03/21 01:27
[1;31m→ [33maccess4096 [m [33m: 叫 [m 223.139.9.75 03/21 01:27
[1;37m推 [33mcreay222 [m [33m: 沒辦法 CHO舔中內鬼一堆 跟台灣一樣 [m 42.76.118.51 03/21 01:32
[1;31m→ [33mal199786215 [m [33m: Who就是笑話 [m 39.12.43.118 03/21 01:39
[1;37m推 [33mbluezero000 [m [33m: 全世界死光剛好，相信中國，死路一 [m 111.250.1.168 03/21 01:40
[1;31m→ [33mbluezero000 [m [33m: 條，自己選的 [m 111.250.1.168 03/21 01:40
[1;37m推 [33mHansLee [m [33m: 第一段翻譯減緩改用拖延是不是更好 [m111.241.141.191 03/21 01:44
[1;37m推 [33mmomofishj [m [33m: [m 114.37.26.150 03/21 02:05
[1;31m→ [33mmomofishj [m [33m: [m 114.37.26.150 03/21 02:06
[1;37m推 [33mleterg [m [33m: 離加入WHO這個政治組織又多了一公里 [m 1.200.34.171 03/21 02:22
[1;37m推 [33mdeshuge1 [m [33m: 推 [m 101.12.102.213 03/21 02:41
[1;31m→ [33mdeshuge1 [m [33m: 垃圾中國。垃圾WHO。 [m 101.12.102.213 03/21 02:41
[1;37m推 [33mcarbbalaa [m [33m: 只有清醒的中國人才有當懦夫的選擇好 [m 42.74.216.222 03/21 02:50
[1;31m→ [33mcarbbalaa [m [33m: 嗎...其他99%都搶著討好+加入他們的黨 [m 42.74.216.222 03/21 02:51
[1;37m推 [33mpearlchendav [m [33m: 推翻譯 [m 27.242.36.189 03/21 03:25